Upcoming Events
Log In
Pricing
Free Trial

Wk 4, Case 5 - Review

HIDE
PrevNext

0:00

Our first case is a 15-year-old male with lateral

0:06

left knee pain after a hyperextension injury

0:09

while playing football, American football,

0:12

two weeks ago.

0:13

So this is a two-week-old injury.

0:15

And the case is a little bit challenging in

0:20

that there are findings in obtuse places.

0:23

So, let me start out with my approach to imaging

0:27

extremities, which I've shared with you before.

0:30

I take a biophysiologic approach to these cases.

0:37

So, if I can latch on to a soft

0:39

tissue or a skeletal finding,

0:41

I use that to figure out the mechanism of injury.

0:44

I also try and figure out whether the abnormality

0:47

that I'm looking at is acute, subacute, chronic,

0:51

or remote,

0:52

and then, I will go on to rate its severity

0:55

and comment with some selective words on

0:58

its overall impact in management.

1:01

So, I usually start out almost every

1:03

case by looking at the axial,

1:05

because that's what comes up first.

1:06

And on a T2-weighted image, there is a

1:10

collection that is not simple fluid.

1:13

How do I know that this is a T2 weighted image?

1:15

It's a heavily water weighted image,

1:17

and water should be white.

1:19

This collection is not white.

1:21

It's gray, and that's because the signal

1:23

is down-averaged from the blood that has

1:27

accumulated in the joint.

1:29

What are some other causes of down-averaging

1:31

of fluid signal, which should be white?

1:34

Well, something heavily proteinaceous could down average,

1:37

but usually that's somewhat heterogeneous.

1:40

You'll see internal signals within.

1:43

So, I do not see a fluid level or a fat fluid level yet,

1:48

but I'm going to be on the lookout for that.

1:51

One of the more common causes for this in

1:53

a 15-year-old is patellar dislocation.

1:55

So that's immediately where my mind would go,

1:58

and I would look at the Medial Patellofemoral Ligament,

2:00

which is right here.

2:02

And the Medial Patellofemoral Ligament comes off

2:05

the femur here at the level of the adductor tubercle,

2:08

and that is intact.

2:09

So, so far, no signs of that.

2:12

A medial patellar fracture. No signs of that.

2:16

A lateral patellar fracture is a sign of patellar

2:19

dislocation, but the fracture is over here,

2:23

not over here. So what are we looking at here?

2:26

We're looking at a saucerized abnormality

2:29

that's broad, that's devoid of edema,

2:32

that does not communicate or

2:33

contact with this fluid.

2:35

So, this abnormality here is absolutely positively

2:39

unrelated to the effusion or hemarthrosis.

2:42

So, this is what makes the case a little difficult.

2:44

This can suck you in and throw you off.

2:47

This is the anterolateral form

2:49

of osteochondritis dissecans,

2:51

which is usually seen in individuals that have

2:54

an element of patellofemoral dysplasia.

2:58

With rest, these usually go away

3:00

in juveniles in 14, 15-year-old boys,

3:03

by the time the growth plate completely closes.

3:06

So these are treated 98% of the time, conservatively.

3:10

So, let's keep going then.

3:12

T2-weighted imaging is not particularly

3:14

sensitive for the skeleton.

3:16

It's good for ligaments.

3:17

It's pretty good for cartilage.

3:19

So, let's go to something more water-weighted.

3:21

Let's go to our sagittal water weighted proton

3:24

density fat suppression image.

3:26

Now, you know it's fat-suppressed

3:28

because the fat is dark.

3:30

When you look at the echo time,

3:32

I like to have my echo times around 40.

3:34

This one's a little short, but that's okay.

3:36

We're not going to spend much

3:38

time on protocol right now.

3:40

And this is where you would see the patellar

3:42

dislocation fracture. Does not have that.

3:44

You go to the other side,

3:46

and you do have

3:47

an impaction injury of the femoral condyle.

3:52

Now, how do I know that's an impaction injury?

3:55

Well, I know because it has this sort of starburst,

3:58

ill defined pattern to it.

4:01

You almost don't see any fracture lines.

4:03

Let's go to the T1-weighted image.

4:05

It looks like it bursts on the scene.

4:08

You've got these speckled areas of white signal,

4:11

and then it even crosses the

4:12

growth plate right here.

4:14

I wouldn't ascribe the term Salter-Harris to it

4:17

because that's a plain film grading system.

4:20

There's no line going through it.

4:22

So, I wouldn't try and use

4:23

a Salter-Harris grading system here.

4:25

But this star burst effect where you have these

4:28

little speckled areas of fat signal intensity,

4:31

very typical of somebody that's taken

4:33

a direct blow to the knee.

4:36

This is also not a good place where you would

4:38

get a typical varus or valgus type.

4:43

This is the type of fracture you'd see in patellar dislocation,

4:46

but on the other side of the knee,

4:48

on the lateral side.

4:49

So this person took a blow to the medial side of

4:52

the knee and has what I call an impaction

4:55

fracture that involves the growth plate.

4:58

I would not use Salter-Harris

5:00

grading in this instance.

5:02

I would say that the patient has a hemarthrosis.

5:05

Again, I'm looking for a blood fluid

5:08

level or a fat fluid level,

5:10

and I do see a blood fluid level right there.

5:13

If you look very carefully,

5:14

I'll take out the lettering so it shows

5:16

up a little better right here.

5:18

There's the layering right there.

5:20

You go over to the T1-weighted image,

5:21

and it's a little bit bright.

5:23

So, that is a little bit of fat that's floating

5:25

superficially right there.

5:27

So we do have a fat fluid level,

5:29

the cellular components of the blood layer, dependently.

5:32

So we've got this osteochondral defect,

5:35

which is consistent with the anterolateral form of

5:38

osteochondritis dissecans.

5:41

How do we know that?

5:42

It's very broad, it's very well defined.

5:45

It's a juvenile. So that fits.

5:47

And we're going to come back to that

5:48

diagnosis a little bit later.

5:50

We've taken a blow to the anteromedial knee.

5:53

So what does that mean? If we've taken a blow

5:56

to the anteromedial knee?

5:57

In my mind, biophysiologically, bioanatomically,

6:02

I want to check the posterolateral corner.

6:05

Because if you hit somebody here,

6:08

you'll put stress over here.

6:11

So let's check that posterolateral corner,

6:13

which looks a little bit swollen right here.

6:17

Let's go right to it in the sagittal projection.

6:21

And here it is.

6:23

Here's the posterolateral corner.

6:26

And that corner consists of

6:28

the meniscopopliteal fascicles.

6:32

There's an upper one and a lower one.

6:35

They go across.

6:37

So when you get to the inside of the meniscus,

6:43

it looks a little bit attenuated right there.

6:46

And right there,

6:48

you've truncated, you're missing somewhat

6:50

this lower fascicle.

6:52

There it comes back again.

6:53

So there's a question as to whether the

6:55

meniscocapsular attachments are torn.

6:58

But more importantly,

6:59

there is a meniscopopliteal ligament right there.

7:03

And you can see it makes a little curve.

7:06

It's a little stretched out,

7:08

still present on the next cut.

7:10

It has a little partial tear in it.

7:11

So there's a low grade injury to the menisco...

7:14

sorry, the popliteofibular ligament.

7:18

And then behind that,

7:19

these little shards right here.

7:21

I'll draw over one.

7:23

I'll draw over this one and this one.

7:26

And they should be connected to each other.

7:29

They should be connected like that.

7:30

Now, I'll take it away.

7:32

That is the arcuit right there.

7:35

So the arcuit ligament is torn.

7:37

There's a paplateofibular ligament strain.

7:40

So, there's a posterolateral corner injury.

7:43

And that's pretty much the case.

7:45

So your conclusion would read something like,

7:48

"Extensive impaction fracture of the medial femoral

7:52

condyle, resulting in a posterolateral corner injury

7:57

with partial tear of the popliteofibular ligament

8:01

and arcuit."

8:02

Next paragraph,

8:03

"Incidentally noted is osteochondritis dissecans of the

8:08

anterolateral femoral condyle.

8:10

And by the way,

8:11

that is the second most common location

8:14

in a juvenile in the knee

8:16

for osteochondritis dissecans,

8:18

the most common and the most important,

8:21

or the most common is the lateral aspect of the

8:24

medial femoral condyle.

Report

Patient History
14-year-old with anterior knee pain and swelling after a football injury.

Findings
Menisci:

Medial Meniscus: Intact.

Lateral Meniscus: Intact.

Ligaments:

Anterior Cruciate Ligament: Intact.

Posterior Cruciate Ligament: Intact.

Medial Collateral Ligament: Slightly thickened, contused proximal tibial collateral ligament associated with subtle periligamentous edema/contusion.

Lateral Collateral Ligament: Thickened proximal fibular collateral ligament associated with periligamentous edema, consistent with low-grade sprain.

Posterolateral Corner Structures: Diffuse swelling of the arcuate ligament, associated with periligamentous edema, consistent with low-grade sprain. Diffuse moderate edema surrounding the popliteus myotendinous unit without macro tear or fiber waviness, consistent with a low grade (grade 1) myotendinous strain. Popliteofibular ligament intact but mildly swollen. Popliteal fascicles intact.

Posteromedial Corner Structures: Intact.

Extensor Mechanism:

Patellar Tendon: Intact.

Distal Quadriceps Tendon: Intact.

Medial Patellofemoral Ligament: Diffusely stretched, likely due to large knee joint effusion/arthrosis, but intact.

Medial and Lateral Patellar Retinacula: Diffusely stretched bilaterally is due to large hemarthrosis.

Hoffa Fat Pad: Mildly thickened infrapatellar plica. Otherwise unremarkable.

Articulations:

Patellofemoral Compartment: Low-grade trochlear dysplasia with trochlear sulcus insufficiency (Dejour A). Slightly lateralized patella could be attributed to the large hemarthrosis versus patellofemoral ligament injury. Borderline TT-TG distance measuring 1.5 cm. Incidental chronic, lateral, peripherally sclerotic, trochlear osteochondritis dissecans, measuring 2.4 x 1.2 cm diameter and 0.6 cm in depth. Overlying cartilage intact but demonstrates low-grade chondromalacia. No hyperintense fluid cleft to suggest potentially unstable fragment. No displaced fragment.

Medial Compartment: Normal.

Lateral Compartment: Normal.

General:

Bones: Diffuse direct medullary(enchondral) bone impaction fracture involving the medial aspect of the medial femoral epicondyle with associated high-grade confluent osteoedema/contusion extending through the medial femoral condyle epiphysis and metaphysis. No cortical depression.

Further subcortical contusion with osteoedema is noted at the posterolateral aspect of the medial femoral condyle.

Low-grade osteoedema consistent with contusion involving the inferior posterior margin of the lateral tibial epiphysis supporting a varus mechanism of injury.

Incidental note is made of mild lateral femoral condylar dysplasia, in addition to trochlear dysplasia.

Effusion: Large suprapatellar effusion/hemarthrosis with reactive capsular synovitis.

Baker’s Cyst: None.

Loose Bodies: None.

Soft tissue and Neurovascular: Unremarkable.

Conclusion
Evidence for recent varus mechanism of injury with medial impaction and the following findings:

1.Extensive direct impaction fracture of the medial femoral epicondyle with osteoedema extending to involve the medial femoral epiphysis and metaphysis.
2.Low-grade posterolateral corner sprain involving the arcuate ligament, popliteus myotendinous unit, popliteofibular ligament and proximal fibular collateral ligament. No high-grade injury, disruption or evidence for posterolateral instability.
3.Large knee joint effusion/hemarthrosis.
4.Incidental unrelated chronic anterolateral trochlear osteochondritis dissecans on a background of trochlear and lateral femoral condyle dysplasia. No evidence for unstable or displaced fragment.

Case Discussion

Faculty

Stephen J Pomeranz, MD

Chief Medical Officer, ProScan Imaging. Founder, MRI Online

ProScan Imaging

Jenny T Bencardino, MD

Vice-Chair, Academic Affairs Department of Radiology

Montefiore Radiology

Edward Smitaman, MD

Clinical Associate Professor

University of California San Diego

Tags

Musculoskeletal (MSK)

MRI

Knee

© 2025 Medality. All Rights Reserved.

Contact UsTerms of UsePrivacy Policy