Get a Group Membership for your Organization. Free Trial
Pricing
Free TrialLogin

Case Review: 14 Year Old Male Who Fell On Outstretched Hand

HIDE
PrevNext

0:00

Here's a 14 year old who fell on an outstretched

0:03

hand and now has radial sided snuffbox type pain.

0:08

This injury that I'm about to show you is

0:11

typically associated with fall on an outstretched

0:14

hand, also known as a Fusch mechanism of

0:17

fall, usually with slight radial deviation.

0:21

We've got, on the far left, a coronal

0:24

proton density fat suppression.

0:26

The growth plates are open.

0:28

In the middle, we've got a T1 spin

0:30

echo, which any scanner can do.

0:32

And on the right, a gradient echo, which is

0:35

not typically a bone marrow sensitive sequence,

0:38

although this one does show the pathology.

0:41

So the obvious abnormality is edema in the scaphoid.

0:45

A common mistake is to call this a contusion.

0:49

It is not a contusion.

0:51

A contusion is a bruise.

0:53

A bruise is an ill defined, ecchymotic

0:57

thing that you see in your skin.

0:58

You don't see a line in your skin

1:00

when you have a bruise, do you?

1:03

And you don't see a line if

1:06

you have a simple contusion.

1:07

But in this case, we see a line that is somewhat

1:10

convoluted or serpiginous or irregular in the

1:14

waist of the scaphoid, best seen on the T1 weighted

1:17

image, although if you look very carefully on the

1:20

waist You can see a few spidery lines throughout

1:24

the waist of the scaphoid on the proton density

1:27

fat suppression sensitive bone scan like sequence.

1:32

If you look very carefully and perhaps or

1:35

perhaps not on plain film, you'll see it.

1:38

There is a tiny cortical step off.

1:42

This step off is missed 50 percent of the time.

1:45

On plain film, you may see loss

1:48

or effacement of the fat pad.

1:50

that sits directly radial to the scaphoid.

1:55

So this is a fracture of the waist of the scaphoid.

1:58

I have no problem with you saying

2:00

it's a microtrabecular fracture.

2:02

I have no problem saying, or have you

2:04

say, that it's a hairline fracture.

2:07

But you must use the F word, the fracture word.

2:11

Contusion simply won't cut it.

2:15

Now fractures of the scaphoid are usually

2:18

located most commonly in the trapezium,

2:20

in the mid-pole, 70 percent of the time.

2:23

Approximately 10 percent of the time, distally 20

2:27

percent of the time in the region of the tubercle.

2:30

The blood supply to the scaphoid comes off

2:33

dorsal branches of the radial artery and

2:35

penetrates the scaphoid via various small

2:39

osseous foramina.

2:43

But the pole gets a pretty good blood supply from the

2:46

radial artery branches. And a lot of this blood supply

2:50

trickles on back to the waist and proximal pole.

2:53

So if you whack or cut the middle of the scaphoid with

2:57

a fracture, that blood supply doesn't get a chance to

3:01

trickle all the way back to the proximal pole, and it's

3:04

the proximal pole that's at risk because it's in part

3:09

dependent on the blood supply from the distal pole.

3:14

Now what else can we say about scaphoid fractures?

3:17

That will help us qualify our report.

3:21

Well, we've already talked about this cortical

3:22

step-off that helps you categorize this

3:26

as a fracture, a microtrabecular fracture.

3:30

We also look at these small spidery lines

3:34

and see if there's a clear-cut, consistent

3:38

separation of one to two millimeters.

3:42

And in that separation gap, you'll see some

3:44

high signal intensity, fluid-like signals.

3:48

We do not see that in this case.

3:50

Thus, the designation microtrabecular or stable

3:54

scaphoid fracture is fair to use in your report.

4:00

So 1 to 2 millimeters of high fluid-like signal

4:03

in these lines pushes you more towards an

4:06

unstable fracture or an unstable macro fracture.

4:13

What are some other signs of potential instability?

4:17

Well, greater than 15 degrees of

4:19

angulation of the fracture fragments.

4:22

Also unstable, obviously, would be a

4:24

transscaphoid perilunate dislocation,

4:26

comminution, macrocomminution, and a proximal

4:32

pole fracture would be considered unstable.

4:37

Couple of classifications,

4:37

and by the way, those characterizations of

4:41

stability were described by Herbert.

4:43

The male classification is broken down into

4:47

not stability versus instability, but location.

4:50

Proximal pole, mid pole, distal pole, and as we

4:54

said, 10%, 70%, 20%, and then we break down the

4:58

distal ones into ones that involve the tubercle

5:02

and ones that involve the tubercle with the male.

5:04

The articular surface.

5:06

Let's scroll for a moment,

5:07

and we'll scroll them all together.

5:09

And just let your eye do the walking

5:12

through the yellow pages here.

5:14

And do notice that the intensity in the

5:17

waist on the gradient echo image is far

5:19

less conspicuous and far less informative

5:23

than the two other sequences we have here.

5:24

This is not a medullary bone sequence at all.

5:28

It's an articular cartilage sequence.

5:30

It's a ligament sequence.

5:32

It's a fibrocartilage sequence,

5:34

but not really a bone sequence.

5:36

And as your eye does the walking through the marrow,

5:40

have your eye get adjusted to these little spidery

5:43

lines, both on the T1-weighted image and on the

5:47

proton density fat suppression image, which makes

5:50

this the F word, the fracture word, the micro

5:54

trabecular fracture word, the hairline fracture

5:57

word, not simply the contusion word, this one

6:00

being stable, involving the most common location.

6:03

The scaphoid waist, 70% of scaphoid fractures.

Report

Faculty

Stephen J Pomeranz, MD

Chief Medical Officer, ProScan Imaging. Founder, MRI Online

ProScan Imaging

Tags

Trauma

Non-infectious Inflammatory

Musculoskeletal (MSK)

MRI

Hand & Wrist

© 2024 MRI Online. All Rights Reserved.

Contact UsTerms of UsePrivacy Policy